AI is stealing our art, new artist lawsuit claims
Lawsuit alleges copyright infringement over training data for AI
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
The battle between artists andAIis set for a legal showdown as one group of artists prepares to take on Stability AI, Midjourney, and DeviantArt’s DreamUp in the first US federal class-action lawsuit of its kind.
Sarah Andersen, Kelly McKernan, Karla Ortiz claim the organizations in question are co-conspirators in “the illegal use of copyrighted works.” It’s alleged that an estimated five billion images were used to train AI - all without the artists’ consent.
According to thelegal filing, which goes as far as to describe DeviantArt’s use of generative AI images as “betrayal of its artist community”, the plaintiffs “seek to end this blatant and enormous infringement of their rights their professions are eliminated” by AI-powereddigital art software.
AI art in the frame
Not everyone is convinced.
Some said the court document fundamentally misrepresented how generative AI art actually works. The class-action complaint appeared to suggest the technology effectively copies existing copyrighted works, rather than create new images influenced by the training data, as anyone who toyed with Dall-E will know.
Others, even those with a strong record of supporting artists’ rights in the field of artificial intelligence, remain concerned about what the outcome might mean for the future of AI-generated artwork. After all, not only are the plaintiffs seeking financial compensation. They’re also demanding alterations on a technical level, “including but not limited to making changes to its Defendants’ AI Image Products.”
And Andersen, McKernan, and Ortiz are not the only ones trying to drag AI art platforms before the beak.
Are you a pro? Subscribe to our newsletter
Sign up to the TechRadar Pro newsletter to get all the top news, opinion, features and guidance your business needs to succeed!
Adobe is almost definitely using your content to train AI>We’ve rounded up the best free drawing software>What is AI capable of, really?
Famedstock photosite Getty Images has also threatened to sue Stability AI, the group behind Stability Diffusion, for copyright infringement. In apress statement, the company - itself a controversial figure in the photographic world due to its licensing practices - confirmed it has begun legal proceedings in the UK’s High Court of Justice. It claims Stability AI copied and processed millions of copyrighted images and metadata for training.
“Getty Images believes artificial intelligence has the potential to stimulate creative endeavors. Accordingly, Getty Images provided licenses to leading technology innovators for purposes related to training artificial intelligence systems in a manner that respects personal and intellectual property rights. Stability AI did not seek any such license from Getty Images and instead, we believe, chose to ignore viable licensing options and long‑standing legal protections in pursuit of their stand‑alone commercial interests,” the photo firm said.
Late last year,VentureBeatdiscussed the legalities of generative AI art after typographer and lawyer Matthew Butterick - who is also involved in the latest class-action complaint - claimed the GitHub Copilot AI used his source code to train its data.
At the time, one lawyer told the website that he believed “the arguments are going to be [boiled down to] fair use versus infringement.” Another law academic warned that any legal wranglings are likely to land in the Supreme Court, potentially taking years to resolve.
If the lawsuit brought by Andersen, McKernan, and Ortiz is successful, artists and users alike could be in for the long haul and a whole lot of uncertainty.
Steve is TechRadar Pro’s B2B Editor for Creative & Hardware. He began in tech journalism reviewing photo editors and video editing software at the magazine Web User, where he also covered technology news, features, and how-to guides. Today, he and his team of reviewers test out a range of creative software, hardware, and office furniture. Once upon a time, he wrote TV commercials and movie trailers. Relentless champion of the Oxford comma.
Best secure file transfer solution of 2024
Best lightweight Linux distro of 2024
Latest Google Pixel update includes surprise launch of Android 15’s best battery feature
