Is this the perfect excuse not to activate your webcam for work calls?
This employee took the battle to court - and won
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
A Netherlands-based employee of Chetu, a Florida company, has won a court case against their employer for unfair dismissal on the subject of remote workwebcamsurveillance.
The worker was asked to enable screen sharing and webcam access for an entire working day while attending a training program, but after refusing to do so, faced the sack. This may have been above board in Florida where workers or companies are not required to give any notice or reason for terminating a contract, however employment rules around the globe offer different levels of protection.
According to the publicly available court documents issued by the Court of Zeeland West-Brabant, the worker explained to the company:
“I don’t feel comfortable being monitored for 9 hours a day by a camera. This is an invasion of myprivacyand makes me feel really uncomfortable. That’s the reason why my camera isn’t on. You can already monitor all activities on my laptop and I am sharing my screen.”
Monitoring staff via webcam
The following day, Chetu notified the worker of their contract’s termination byemail, on the grounds of refusal to work and insubordination.
Ultimately, the court ruled in the worker’s favor, insisting that Chetu pay the claimant $2,600 in unpaid salary, $9,245 in worker transition assistance, and a further $8,150 on the basis of wrongful contract termination. The fines extended to the equivalent of 23 days’ holiday pay, an 8% holiday allowance, and any court and late payment fees incurred, bringing the total to nearly $50,000.
The best video conferencing software>Businesses are feeling more confident about securing hybrid work>Businesses still have a long way to go to sort the biggest hybrid work problem
The court summarized that “camera surveillance during nine hours a day is disproportionate and not allowed in the Netherlands. In addition, he was already checked for output via software installed on his laptop.” It continues: “There was no question of refusal to work.”
Are you a pro? Subscribe to our newsletter
Sign up to the TechRadar Pro newsletter to get all the top news, opinion, features and guidance your business needs to succeed!
The court notes also highlight the company’s lack of statement or defence against this case, alongside the fact that Chetu did not appear at the hearing.
Chetu has since dissolved its Dutch branch, and has deregistered from the country’s trade register as of September 1, 2022.
TechRadar Prohas asked the company for a response to the ruling.
With several years’ experience freelancing in tech and automotive circles, Craig’s specific interests lie in technology that is designed to better our lives, including AI and ML, productivity aids, and smart fitness. He is also passionate about cars and the decarbonisation of personal transportation. As an avid bargain-hunter, you can be sure that any deal Craig finds is top value!
This new malware utilizes a rare programming language to evade traditional detection methods
Google puts Nvidia on high alert as it showcases Trillium, its rival AI chip, while promising to bring H200 Tensor Core GPUs within days
I’ve been covering Apple Watch deals for years – This is the one model most people should buy on Black Friday
